Skip to content

Compared

Online coaching, or a personal trainer?

They solve different problems. A personal trainer stands next to you for an hour. An online coach reads your whole week. Which one you need depends on where you are.

Part of Choosing a coach

The difference

An hour, or the whole week.

Personal trainer

In the gym, in person

Technique corrected while you lift, someone who sets the pace and counts the reps. Paid per session. What happens in the rest of the week is yours.

Online coach

A system for the week

The programme, the nutrition, the recovery and a check-in that reads all of it together. Paid per month. You train on your own, and you are expected to.

Choose a trainer

A personal trainer fits when:

  1. You are in your first year

    The lifts have to be learned before a system around them makes sense.

  2. Your technique is not yet reliable

    A squat or a deadlift is corrected fastest by someone watching it.

  3. You need someone present to train at all

    That is what a session in the diary is for.

Choose online coaching

Online coaching fits when:

  1. You have trained for two years or more

    And the returns have flattened, however hard the year was.

  2. Your training is fine, the rest is not

    Nutrition and recovery that are not connected to the programme are the usual gap.

  3. You have a date

    A show or a shoot needs a timeline, written backwards.

  4. Your week does not fit a fixed slot

    The plan travels with you, and the check-in goes in when it suits.

What Struqture is

Struqture is online coaching.

Jonathan Kantor does not give personal training. The plan, the nutrition, the weekly check-ins and the adjustments run through the Struqture app, wherever you train.

Read on: the app, what coaching costs, Cape Town.

Questions

Asked, answered.

Does online fitness coaching work?

It works for people who execute on their own. The plan is written for you and read on a fixed cadence, but nobody stands next to you. That is why Struqture asks for an application and declines people it does not expect to help.

Is online coaching cheaper than a personal trainer?

Online coaching is paid per month and a trainer per session, so it depends on how often you would see the trainer. Struqture coaching costs between R 1 250 and R 2 000 per month.

Can I combine a trainer with online coaching?

Yes. A trainer for technique and an online coach for the system do not conflict, as long as one programme leads. Say so in your application.

The next step

Not sure which one? Start with the read.

The Structure Assessment takes under two minutes and says where your system breaks. If a trainer is the better choice, it will say so.

Updated